Posted: 04/02/08
Stop Loss (2008)
by Hank Yuloff

FM Home
now playing
coming soon
on the box
video/DVD
behind the scenes
wayne case
film noir
horror film
silent cinema
american cinematheque
letters
links
about fm


Since September, 2001 630,000 of our best and brightest have been sent to Afghanistan and Iraq to either, a) fight to protect democracy and b) fulfill the Bush administration's dream of privatization of all government services and further concentrate what is left of our country's wealth in the hands of the very few.  81,000 have been prevented from leaving the military when their military contract expired.  They have been stop-lossed, a loophole which allows the Bush government to keep them on the merry go round of never ending tours in the Iraq quagmire. Stop Loss was originally used to allow the US government to not lose talented soldiers during a time of war.  Since Bush declared that his war was over, (see Mission Accomplished banner on USS Lincoln sitting within sight of San Diego and Bush flying out to it in order to show his machismo) it is conceivable that stop-lossing our soldiers is yet another thing which George W Bush has lied about.

Stop Loss is about one of those 81,000.  Sergeant Brandon King (Ryan Phillippe from Flags of Our Fathers, Crash, Breach) has been awarded the Bronze star for valor and a purple heart. He has run over 100 missions in Iraq and is finally about to be released. When he is informed at his exit interview that he has been reassigned, something snaps. He says he hasn't flipped. He is just "pissed off."  He thinks that running off to Washington, DC to speak with his senator will help.  Talk to a TEXAS senator about getting out of the army? Come on, son. What in the name of Crawford do you think he is going to do for you?

I think that the movie was a bit simplistic in that within King's squad we see a sample of everything that happens to our troops - one is horribly maimed but considers himself lucky to be alive, three die on what was to be their last mission, one is coerced into re-enlisitng with a promotion, one commits suicide, and all of the survivors suffer from various levels of post traumatic stress and alcoholism.  I know that writer/director Kimberly Peirce had to deal with a very complicated subject, but this was a glaring red light of amateurism. The scenes of battle are well shot and at no time do we ever get the feeling that the movie is unsupportive of those who would put themselves in harm's way to defend our country.  It is the system which has let them down.

By the way, the numbers I quoted in the first paragraph, do not include the extra 30,000 which Bush put into Iraq as an escalation (ok, so he calls it a surge).  The numbers of those troops who have been stop lossed has not been revealed by the Bush Crime Family.

Hank Yuloff is a co-founder of Film Monthly and film critic living in Los Angeles.

Got a problem? Email us at filmmonthly@hotmail.com