Posted: 11/11/03
© 2003 Filmmonthly.com
Shattered Glass (2003)
by Hank Yuloff


FM Home
now playing
coming soon
video/DVD
behind the scenes
wayne case
film noir
horror film
silent cinema
american cinematheque
television
fm sound
letters
links
about fm


The only question I have for the characters in Shattered Glass is a  big one:  At The New Republic, a magazine that prided itself on truth, justice, and the American Way; a publication that looked down on the  New York Times as being less than perfect journalistically; how was it possible that a writer lied in 27 out of 41 articles produced for the magazine without it being caught?  And when it was caught, why was it  by a competitor?

That Shattered Glass is based on a true story is what saves me from slamming what would be an obvious impossibility.  But yet it happened  so I must just be amazed.  And the telling of the story is a great tale  worth seeing.

Stephen Glass (Hayden Christensen) was a new wunderkind reporter for  The New Republic.  He came up with great sources on great pieces that  tweaked both major political parties and other organizations that needed to  have the light of day shown upon them.  But when he runs an article on a computer hacker that attacks a nonexistent software company, the  emperor's new clothes are shown to be invisible by an online magazine (like this  one - only better funded).  The house of cards that he has built begins to crumble, one lucky seven at a time until he is forced to admit that  whole article is a sham.  

In my other life outside writing for this e-zine,  I own a promotional products company that does a lot of screen printing.  Recently I fired  a screen printer because every other word that come out of her mouth was  a lie.  And the other words were to cover up those lies.  So as I sat in Shattered Glass and listened to reporter Stephen Glass dance around his lies, I felt  the same anger bubbling just below the surface.  That is  how I knew that Hayden Christensen (Life as a House, Star Wars Episode II)  did a good job of acting.  He was the printer who could never tell the  truth.  He was captivatingly irritating.

His editors are equally good.  Peter Sarsgaard (Empire, K-19) is Chuck Lane, a man, at first, we are supposed to hate for his obnoxious  manner.  First time director Billy Ray (after writing 7 screenplays) did a great job of setting us up because when we see Sarsgaard develop into a fine editor and defender of the magazine, he absolutely shines.  Likewise  Hank Azaria (The Birdcage, Mad About You) is incredible as editor Michael Kelly.

Shattered Glass should be a must see by every student studying  journalism today.  When I was in college, we had two unofficial sayings at the  paper:  "The Daily Aztec, We Never Sleep" and "The Daily Aztec: We Get It  Right, Almost All The Time."  While these were both said in jest, they both  serve to underlay facts that are still true today:  Journalists must be ever vigilant. And journalists must always get it right because the consequences are far too great when they blow it.  

Don't blow it - go see Shattered Glass.

Hank Yuloff was an ADVERTISING guy at his college newspaper so  everything he writes about it must therefore be suspect.    is a complete anti-gun guy and thinks his father in law is the perfect example of why guns should not be allowed on the street.  

Got a problem? Email us at filmmonthly@hotmail.com

Please visit our friends at HKFlix.com.